On January 5, 2009, the 110th
Congress ended. All legislation that was not passed by both
houses of Congress came to an end. New orphan works
legislation will need to be introduced in the 111th
Congress for it to be reconsidered in the future. No orphan
works legislation is currently before Congress. The same
version of S. 2913 and H.R. 5889 could be reintroduced with no changes
or a few / some / numerous changes could be made to
either version before they are reintroduced by an
interested Member of Congress. Any Member of Congress
could reintroduce orphan works legislation, although the
tradition is that the same Member(s) of Congress who
introduced similar legislation in the prior Congress do
so again.
Due to internal
rules adopted by Democratic Party members in the U.S. House
of Representatives, Congressman Berman is no longer the
Chairman of the Intellectual Property Subcommittee of the
House Judiciary Committee in 2009. Former Subcommittee
Chairman Berman is now the Chairman of the entire House
International Relations Committee. Mr. Berman was not
replaced on the Intellectual Property Subcommittee since
there is no Intellectual Property Subcommittee of the House
Judiciary Committee in the 111th Congress. Orphan works and
all other intellectual property issues (copyrights,
trademarks, and patents) will be handled by the full
Judiciary Committee, rather than one of its Subcommittees.
This will result in less chance to debate the new version
of the legislation and related amendments.
On September 26, 2008, the Senate passed
S. 2913 by unanimous consent, i.e. not one
Senator objected to its passage.
On August 8, 2008, the Office of Advocacy of the Small
Business Administration held a workshop on orphan works in
New York City. A number of opponents from the visual arts
and photographic community spoke at the two hour event. No
supporters of the legislation were invited to participate.
The event was not noticed in the Federal Register, nor does
it appear that a formal record of the event was kept.
(Video of the event is available however)
In July 2008, the full House Judiciary Committee deferred
its planned markup on H.R. 5889 due to opposition from the copyright
user community to additional changes to the legislation
desired by large copyright owners. Objections from the
visual arts community had little impact upon the
decision to defer the markup.
In June and July 2008, there were two attempts by the full
Senate to pass S. 2913 by unanimous consent, but the
legislation was blocked by Republican Members of the
Senate upset over the slow pace of judicial nominations
and copyright user complaints over the state sovereign
immunity issue. Senator Leahy is responsible for
deciding when federal judges have their confirmation
votes by the Senate and some Republican Senators were
upset with the scheduling of votes on these judges. As a
result, they objected to the unanimous consent passage
of S. 2913 which is sponsored by Senator Leahy.
This use of anonymous holds is not uncommon in the
Senate, especially when votes on federal judges are
involved.
On June 20, 2008, the Congressional Budget Office released
its formal budget score (pdf) of S. 2913. A budget score is required of all
new legislation to estimate the financial impact of new
legislation to the federal and state governments and to
the public. CBO estimates a $2 million federal cost over
four years for the legislation.
On May 15, 2008, the Senate Judiciary Committee agreed by a
"voice vote" to S. 2913 after making several changes to the
bill in a "manager's amendment."
On May 7, 2008, the House Judiciary Committee's
Subcommittee on Courts, the Internet, Intellectual Property
agreed by a "voice vote" to send H.R. 5889 to the full House Judiciary Committee
after making several changes to the bill in a "manager's
amendment." More changes will be made at the full
Committee markup.
On April 24, 2008, two different versions of the Orphan
Works Act were introduced - H.R. 5889 and S. 2913.
On March 13, 2008, the Subcommittee on Courts, Internet, and
Intellectual Property of the U.S. House Judiciary Committee
held an oversight hearing on orphan
works. This
restarted the legislative process on orphan works
legislation for 2008. The prior legislation,
H.R. 5439, expired at the end of the previous
Congress in 2006.